Should kids have cell phones? Just to be exact, should sixth-graders have cell phones?
Let me see if I can formulate the issue a bit better:
Should I get my son a cell phone?
Hes modest in his demands. He says hell settle for an iPhone 4. Its not like he wants the latest model.
I am serious. What should I do?
I didnt need one when I was his age. They didnt exist then.
Has the world reorganized itself so that a kid his age really does need a phone?
When I was a kid I always had a dime in case I needed to reach my parents. Both my parents worked, and I knew where they worked, and I could pretty much count on reaching them.
I dont remember actually ever calling my parents. But I do remember the dime.
Well, there are no phone booths any more, at least not where I live. So thats a reason in favor.
A part of me loves the idea that he would have a phone. After all, as somebody once said, mobile phones are basically tracking devices with a few add-on features. And I love the idea that my son, in exchange for his phone privileges, would have to check in with me and keep me apprised of his movements.
And then theres the fact that Im separated from his mother. A phone would give me access to him, directly, without having to go through his mother. Would that be good for him? Or me? I am his father, after all.
Im sure it never occurred to my parents to want to check up on me or have me check in on them. Their idea was: if we dont hear anything, things must be OK. Was that a good policy? I dont know. But it is a striking fact that I dont know any parents who have that policy today. I think it was pretty common when I was a kid.
OK, enough about me. Heres the serious point: cell phones are powerful. I dont know anybody, at least not anybody grown up, who lived through the great transition brought on by the technologys arrival who doesnt have a love/hate relationship with the phone. The device is always with us, always beckoning, always tempting us to give in to whatever kind of urge it is that makes us check text, phone, Twitter, Facebook, email how many times an hour?
As long-time readers of this blog know, I am something of a skeptic about addiction-talk. But it seems like a good case can be made that we are addicted to our mobile devices. They obsess us. They interfere with our engagement with the world around us. They afford us pleasure, but also anxiety ” they never let us rest!
Whether they are addictive or not, I think it is safe to say that for many of us they are problematic. We check our cell phones with compulsion, much as we might feel compelled to steal a glimpse at our reflection in the glass as we walk by.
I dont claim to understand the curious cocktail of vanity, urgency, curiosity, pleasure and anxiety that cell phones seem to serve up.
What I know is that it makes me nervous to think I should be serving that up to my son! Isnt that like buying your son his first smoke? And isnt that sort of gross? And isnt he too young anyway?
What do you think?